UK infrastructure needs urgent overhaul says Arup
The UK’s infrastructure delivery model is failing, and a major engineering firm is calling for reforms to address the problems.
Arup, a global design and consulting company, states that current projects are slow, over budget, and often ignore local priorities. It proposes a shift toward locally led initiatives with flexible financing to better serve communities and boost economic growth.
Top-down projects miss the mark
Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham has pledged to overhaul the system. His approach focuses on economic growth across all areas, supported by what he describes as a “rewired state.” Connecting people and places remains central to improving living standards and opportunities.
Burnham’s time in office has exposed flaws in the existing model. Projects move slowly, exceed budgets, and are designed without input from those they affect. The cancellation of HS2’s second phase last year left the North West and Midlands without a vital rail link, while congestion on Europe’s busiest railway persists.
Related: Britain’s AI ambitions hit by science department split
Arup collaborated with Burnham and West Midlands mayor Andy Street to explore alternatives. Rather than starting with engineering limitations, the team focused on the outcomes communities needed. The result was a plan that matched HS2’s benefits at a lower cost.
Comparable regions outperform the UK
The UK lags behind similar European regions in infrastructure performance. Germany’s Rhine-Ruhr area, with a population and industrial base like the Midlands-North West corridor, produces an extra £100 billion in annual output. Stronger transport networks contribute significantly to that difference.
The Netherlands’ Randstad region, another comparable area, has a GDP per capita £20,000 higher than parts of the UK. France has built metro or tram systems in every city with over 150,000 residents, while UK projects in Leeds and Cambridge remain delayed after years. The gap is clear.
British engineers have long shaped global mobility, from Brunel to Stephenson. Today, their expertise is sought after worldwide, including for the 2032 Brisbane Olympics. The issue is not capability but delivery.
Related: Citi shares drop as Fraser plans deeper cuts
Funding presents another obstacle. The UK’s rigid business case processes often lead to delays. Arup recommends creative financing models that attract private investment by sharing value gains from new infrastructure. Such approaches could help break current deadlocks.
Vision is also lacking. Historic engineering projects set ambitious goals and executed them decisively. Modern initiatives frequently stall in bureaucracy. Arup’s work with UK mayors highlights a better approach: allow local leaders to define their goals, then provide engineering and financial solutions. This marks a move from centralized planning to growth driven by local needs.
The firm believes the new government can speed up reforms. However, meaningful progress requires rethinking how projects are chosen, designed, and funded. Without changes, the divide between political promises and actual results will grow.
